AL-FUNDUQ AS-SIQILLIالفندق الصقلي
AL-FUNDUQ AṢ-ṢIQILLĪ · THE INSTITUTION

The legal framework

The house uses the instruments Italian law already offers to every association.
Every element will be settled with the notary and the lawyer before the first admission.

These pages use the terms of Italian association law (member, assembly, governing body, arbitral panel); in the pages on the life of the house the everyday names apply (rifāq, majlis, majlis al-umanāʾ, hayʾat at-taḥkīm, niẓām ad-dār), which the glossary→ sets beside the former.

Freedom of association and internal discipline

A private association may adopt statutes that bind its members, admit and exclude according to its own procedures, and impose standards of conduct on those who have joined it. The courts review such decisions for procedural fairness and conformity with public policy, and do not substitute their own judgement on the merits of the rules the association has given itself. Sports federations, private schools and professional associations under private law all rest on this foundation, and the discipline some of them impose is considerably heavier than what is proposed here.

The association and the foundation

The association takes the name “Il Fondaco Siciliano — Associazione per le arti e i mestieri”, with the everyday name “Al-Funduq as-Siqilli”, its registered office in the municipality of Catania, unlimited duration and no profit motive. The first step is the constitution of the association by registered private deed, which can open an account, receive contributions and sign the preliminary contract; the recognised foundation is constituted afterwards and receives the property.

Arbitration among the members

The members may agree that disputes among them in contractual and associational matters be decided by an arbitral panel of their choice, according to rules they have themselves adopted. The award so obtained is enforceable in Italy by decree of the court, under the code of civil procedure. The New York Convention of 1958, which more than one hundred and seventy States have ratified, concerns instead the recognition of foreign awards, and it matters here for a concrete rather than a theoretical reason: the masters come from Morocco, which is a party to that Convention, and a dispute with a party or assets abroad is the only one in which the reference has any effect. The mechanism, in any case, is the one on which sports justice and associational arbitration have rested for decades: a community runs a panel of its own within the general law, and the general law enforces the result without reopening the merits.

In the statutes the panel has three members and its jurisdiction stops where the parties’ freedom to dispose stops. Criminal matters, family law and the non-waivable rights of the worker are excluded in every case.

The limits

No criminal jurisdiction. Offences are reported to the authorities as in any other place, and any rule of the house that claimed otherwise would be void, and rightly so.

No family law. Marriage, separation, custody and inheritance remain entirely with the State. The exclusion is absolute and is written into the statutes rather than left to practice.

No obligation on anyone who has not joined. The statutes bind the members and no one else, and cannot be invoked against a spouse, a child, a neighbour or a former member.

No exemption from mandatory rules. Labour standards, safety, taxation and the protection of minors apply in full.

These limits belong to the project, rather than being concessions extracted by a supervisory authority.

We cite the Faro Convention, ratified by Italy in 2020, because it describes exactly what the house wants to be:

“a heritage community consists of people who value specific aspects of cultural heritage which they wish, within the framework of public action, to sustain and transmit to future generations”

Council of Europe Framework Convention on the Value of Cultural Heritage for Society, Faro, 27 October 2005 (CETS No. 199), Article 2(b)

Work

Every employment relationship is framed by the construction agreement for the building phases and by the applicable agreements for the workshop operations, with safety training and regular contributions.

Rules by contract

The rules of the house hold because its members have accepted them by contract. They ask no State for an exemption, nor for a territory.

The distinction matters in practice even more than in theory. An exemption is granted, and what is granted can be withdrawn by the same authority that gave it. A contract is agreed, and its enforcement is the ordinary business of the courts, which will uphold it precisely because they had no part in drafting it. The first route depends on political favour and dies with it; the second depends only on the general law of obligations, which no administration would repeal in order to make life difficult for a school of craftsmen.

The limits

The institution is subject to the criminal, labour, tax and building law of the State, exactly like a private school.

What one obtains

One obtains room for manoeuvre within those constraints, and it is far wider than is commonly believed. Within a private association the members can be bound to rules of conduct, of working dress, of hours, of use of the common property, of admission of new members and of settlement of their own disputes, on terms that no public authority could impose and that none will come to disturb, because the members have accepted them.

The thesis of this project is that the space between what States are willing to concede and what private agreement already allows is wide, largely unused, and enough to build in.

What is needed

To a young man without a trade, without a master and without anyone to answer for him, the house will offer work, a master, obligations towards others and something of his own to be proud of.

A community of a hundred people bound by statutes they have signed needs neither a square kilometre nor a concession: it needs a building, a trade and an enforceable agreement. The first costs little, the second is the oldest thing there is in Europe, and the third is already the law in force.

The words of this page are in the common glossary; the works cited in the sources; the sister house is Riyāḍ al-Uns.

CORRESPONDENCE

Writing to the house

Contact